The bar where the baristas make the coffee and other drinks in Coffeeology. (Piper Baxley)
The bar where the baristas make the coffee and other drinks in Coffeeology.

Piper Baxley

The quest for Delaware’s best coffee shop

November 18, 2022

Chilling fall weather rushes in a new season of sweaters, scarves and of course, pumpkin spice lattes. 

Yet, a new battle emerges from an era of frosty hands and frothy drinks: the search for Delaware’s best coffee shop.

 

Honorable Mentions

Although Delaware is home to many dedicated coffee outlets and cafes, some restaurants deserve recognition for their loyalty to caffeinated beverages and cozy aesthetics. 

 

1808

With decor that will make you say, “why’s that door there?” 1808 is a rustic, comfy and revolutionary destination for everything high-palate—and they have brunch! 

Although their menu changes with the seasons, some classics stick around, including their freshly brewed black coffee. 

The coffee may not be the star of the show, but with freshly powdered beignets or home-made biscuits, it shines like any other.

The restaurant derives its name from the year in which Delaware was founded, 1808, yet it feels larger than the small town it calls home. Swooping ceilings dotted with chandeliers that are dimmed to nothing, just barely illuminating a collection of little memories in the form of stunning photography and, needless to say, a giant black door placed at the helm of the main dining room.

It would be a disservice to not mention 1808 as a haven for breakfast enjoyers. 

 

Hamburger Inn

The 1942 painting “Nighthawks” coming to a main street near you, Hamburger Inn is a classic over-the-counter diner that’s seldom seen in most modern establishments. It’s a refreshing blast from the past, complete with well-loved decorum and superbly soul-warming food. 

Although, it’s not just the scenery that’s old—the Inn is the longest-running diner in Delaware, originally opened in 1932 under the name of the “Senate Restaurant.” It was soon bought by the Hudson family, and known as the beloved “Hamburger Inn” ever since.

The restaurant is a staple of good home-style American food, with heavenly cinnamon rolls and a coffee club that’s been meeting there for over 50 years. 

4. Choffey’s

Piper Baxley

The inside of Choffey’s after they closed.

4. Choffey’s

A break from “corporate coffee” chains, Choffey’s doubles as both an artisan cafe and a homegrown candy store. 

Their chocolates and candles are locally made, with their dairy products supplied by Hartzler Dairy, a company originated in Wayne County, Ohio, located just an hour outside of Delaware.

Their hand-crafted drinks and candies may be a bit sweet for some, with a notably sugar-packed menu, but there are many unique snacks to try for anyone feeling adventurous and particularly sweet-toothed.  

The shop is a Delaware classic and a prime studying location, with antique rocking chairs for those wanting to look sophisticated and comfy at the same time (while gorging on caramel popcorn).

3. Coffeeology

Piper Baxley

People drinking coffee and talking while sitting in Coffeeology.

3. Coffeeology

Autumn contained in a single city corner, Coffeeology is an endearingly rustic shop which serves in more ways than one.

Where lavender and cacao can coincide in beautifully smooth harmony, the cafe boasts many interesting flavors of coffee and other caffeine products.

Along with typical food-oriented items, it is also a store for home decor, jewelry, clothing and candles, most of which are locally made or manufactured.

Coffeeology is host to a wide variety of items, a large array of drinks, and an excess of vintage appeal.

2. Fresh Start

Sidnee Stanley

The front counter at Fresh Start Café and Bakery in downtown Delaware.

2. Fresh Start

The most recent addition to the main street coffee pantheon, Fresh Start is an aptly named breath of fresh air. Although not necessarily as cozy as their artsy caffeine counterparts, the cafe and bakery is a sleek and polished outlet for all things baked and wholesome. 

Pumpkin truffles, coconut macaroons and buttery shortbread cookies line their shelves, illuminated in their culinary perfection. Plus, plenty of adorable succulent plants call Fresh Start home. 

Although there is a limited number of drink menu items, there is a plethora of options for coffee lovers everywhere.

1. Ciao Cafe

Piper Baxley

People eating and talking together at Ciao Cafe.

1. Ciao Cafe

Pastries that look like they were grabbed straight from a painting, hand-crafted flavor-marbled gelato and aesthetic elegance so sharp that it could kill—that’s Ciao.

Possibly one of the most unique outlets in the county, Ciao found a way to brew charm in a cup. With lattes overflowing with tender hazelnut and vanilla, it’s nothing short of impressive how much attention to detail is placed into everything that they do. 

An Italian-American cafe with an industrial feel, its window art depicting Italian banners next to steaming cups of coffee, the place screams character in an otherwise uneventful street corner. 

It’s an absolute gem, coffee-wise at least.

View Comments (1)
Donate to The Talisman
$500
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Rutherford B. Hayes High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

The Talisman • Copyright 2022 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in

Donate to The Talisman
$500
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

1

Comments (1)

All The Talisman Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • C

    Coffee LordNov 18, 2022 at 4:06 pm

    Ngl McDonald’s has the best coffee…..

    Reply